Read their prompt and give feedback on their example essay. Consider the following questions when making your comments:
1) Was the passage a good one to choose?
2) Did the prompt get at the heart of the passage? Why or why not?
3) Did the exemplar adequately address the prompt?
4) Is the exemplar truly an example of a level 9 essay? If so, what was so great about it? If not, what could be improved?